- Fri Mar 29, 2013 2:58 am
#366553
One development I would really love to see is a bit more 'back-door' access, even if unofficial
I agree. While the physical accuracy of Maxwell is very impressive I sometimes feel restricted. I used Vray for a few years before this and although Maxwell has MANY benefits over Vray, I still miss the greater access to the workings of the engine and the freedom to tweak and modify.numerobis wrote:Yes, that's the point... i really can't understand why there still this untouchable rule of staying unbiased while it is already not true anymore (or never has been) as it is now...Half Life wrote:Less required fakery -- so many of the limitations of Maxwell currently force the user to ignore physically accurate approaches to get a suitable result... AGS being just one of dozens of common examples I could use (and please don't tell me AGS is physically accurate, because it is only accurate in as much as it is theoretically possible, but not accurate to real world experience).
There are so many limitations regarding dielectrics, caustics, scattering amd high reflective materials that you have to fake it in any way to get the job done. Maybe it is possible to render strictly unbiased cubes or maybe simple product shots but no archviz scenes. And i can say for me that i would have absolutely no problem to use optimized (biased!) glass and water materials with good looking caustics, refraction and tinted shadows when it then simply works and looks real!!! All the annoying workarounds for these situations are only laughable and still looking fake in most situations. But i have to use them and so all my renders are already biased - so why not do it right and use biased solutions for those special cases when the unbiased solution is not possible? And it seems so, since we already had 8 years now without a proper solution.
Maybe display a big warning sign that you're leaving the unbiased route now at your own risk if you use them... i would have no problem to do it!
One development I would really love to see is a bit more 'back-door' access, even if unofficial

- By Jochen Haug