Any features you'd like to see implemented into Maxwell?
User avatar
By Maximus3D
#238953
Yes please, this would be very useful. Plz NL code thin-sheet sss :)

/ Max
User avatar
By Fernando Tella
#238955
Well, SSS (subsurface scattering) obviously happens under the surface of the object. If it doesn't have volume it doesn't have any effect... I think that what you want can be achieved with some transmittance and high roughness...


Edit:I'm making some tests and I'm wrong with the transmittance part, but sss is working for planes...

Re-edit: Now I think I understand what you mean; if I'm not wrong, sss works now like if the plane had infinite volume, right? I guess we need something in material editor that tells the core: "Hey, treat the object's faces which has this material applyed as if each face is two sided (out-in and in-out) with a thickness of .... 0,01mm"
User avatar
By Mattia Sullini
#238977
I meant right that.. :D
I tried almost the same things you did but as you have spotted by yourself the results were not predictable... are you joining to this wish, then?
User avatar
By Fernando Tella
#238993
Here are my tests:

Scene capture; the red box with the leaf is actually a 1cm thick box; the leaves are planar; box and leaves share the same material:
Image

Render without SSS and transmittance rgb= 0,0,0:
Image

Render without SSS and transmittance rgb= 0,3,0 (almost black very dark green):
Image

Render with SSS and transmittance rgb= 0,3,0:
Image

Render with SSS and transmittance rgb= 15,42,16 (dark green):
Image

Render with SSS and transmittance rgb= 142,210,133 (very light green):
Image

As we can see, Maxwell manages transmittance in planar objects as thickness=0 instead of infinite making them completely transparent with just a bit of transmittance, but with SSS it takes a planar as infinitely thick; we can see in the last one that the box renders as it should while the leaves of the palm scatters light a lot more.
are you joining to this wish, then?
Yes, I am. We need something in material editor to specify a "thin object thickness". A double sided option with thickness would be great.
User avatar
By Mattia Sullini
#239098
Thanks a lot for the tests! Really useful and effective in showing what i meant.

So, is this a known issue?

Thanks a lot for your response, I will update and […]

did you tried luxCore?