[alexxx_95]

for the old man, it was just an overall feeling, and the wrinkles on the forehead were too continuous

and for the eye, too much subtles details , for exemple this dark stain on the translucent limit eye border



Uploaded with ImageShack.us

[sandykoufax]

wow, very sharp analysis.

and tom, you are 10/11.

[Half Life]

The ears gave it away for me on the old man -- I only got 8 of 12 right... the closeup of the girl looked fake in the eyes but with photo retouch that can happen so I go that one wrong. The one I was sure was real was the spiders web and I was wrong... but I didn't take too long looking at them.

Best,
Jason.

[RobMitchell]

I got 11 out of 12, too. The one I got wrong was the spider image. For the old man, the "around the eye" areas looked really CG to me which gave it away.

[tom]

and tom, you are 10/11.

[Bubbaloo]

Nice one. I got 3 wrong. Some of them I recognized as CG because I had seen them before, like the spider web.

The old man, to me looked VERY CG. I couldn't believe it was part of the challenge.

[paperless]

12/12
"Twelve out of twelve answers are correct. Excellent-- a perfect score and a superior performance. "
L

[richardyot]

I thought the old man was obvious Zbrush, but the spider's web really fooled me: those optical aberrations and all the detail with the dewdrops was very well done.

[shen.de]

11/12

the orange key was so blurry I had to guess. the rest was obvious or known through other forums

but the spider web is really great. it's true...

[philip99]

Only 7 right

[NicoR44]

Woow, I think I will call them in a minute!!!

[glebe digital]

9/12